Legal

What Disqualifies a Tenant in Maryland? (2026 Screening Rules)

Blog · Legal · October 31, 2026 · 6 min read

Generally, you can’t screen anyone out over race, color, religion, sex, disability, marital status, familial status, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, source of income or military status, though exceptions exist in certain circumstances. Since October 1, 2026, two new laws have also taken away a lot of the old shortcuts on criminal records and on credit for applicants with housing subsidies. Much depends on whether your written criteria get applied the same way to every person who walks through the door.

Paper rental applications and a manila folder on a wooden desk beside a window overlooking brick rowhouses in Baltimore

Grounds that still hold up for a denial

The subsidy law itself says a landlord may keep weighing commercially reasonable, nondiscriminatory information like landlord references, past lease violations, unpaid utilities, nuisance and property damage. A former landlord who says the tenant left a unit wrecked, and can back it up with photos and a deposit itemization, gives you something defensible. A former landlord who just says they didn’t get along gives you nothing you can write down. Ask each former landlord the same short set of questions, in the same order: did the tenant pay on time, did they leave owing anything, was there damage beyond normal wear, and would you rent to them again? Write down who you spoke with, when, and what they said.

Eviction history is the other big one. When a search turns up a case, read how it ended. Pull the full docket entries. Our walkthrough of the Maryland eviction process explains what each step on a docket means, which helps when you’re reading someone else’s case history. Work in this order: confirm the case belongs to your applicant, read how it ended, then ask the applicant to explain it. As a hypothetical, an applicant’s search shows a filing that the docket marks as dismissed. Note the outcome and their explanation, and compare both to your written criteria.

Write your criteria down before the listing goes live. That means your income ratio, how many landlord references you want, how far back you look at evictions, and what you count as damage. Process applications in the order they arrive. Keep every denial in a file with the reason attached. Keep approvals in the same file with the same detail, along with a copy of each listing as it ran, so you can show one standard applied to everyone.

Criminal records

The Governor signed SB 937 on May 26, 2026, and it took effect October 1, 2026 as a new Subtitle 2A.

Sign and date it. Give the applicant a chance to hand you rehabilitation evidence before you decide, because a denial without that sheet is hard to defend. Answer these on the sheet, in order: what the record shows, how long ago it happened, how it bears on residents or the property, and what the applicant has given you since. Hypothetically, if an applicant hands you an employer letter and a program certificate, list each item by name and note how it affected your view.

On August 31, 2026, the Attorney General’s Civil Rights Division settled with Bay Management Group over “clean criminal background” language in its ads. The company agreed to remove that language, adopt an individualized-assessment policy and pay civil penalties. Go through every listing template you use, on every site, and cut anything along the lines of “no felonies” or “clean record required.” Check old Craigslist reposts too. Screenshot each revised listing and note the date you changed it.

Income, credit and voucher holders

Run your income test against the tenant’s share only. If you ask a market-rate applicant for 3 times the rent, ask the voucher holder for 3 times their portion.

The bigger change came with SB 335, Chapter 773, signed May 26, 2026. Since October 1, 2026, if an applicant will pay with an income-based housing subsidy, you generally can’t refuse them because of their income, their credit score, having no score at all, or bad credit from a stretch when they had no subsidy. You can still confirm they can afford the part of the rent the subsidy doesn’t cover. A violation is a discriminatory housing practice, enforced by the Maryland Commission on Civil Rights.

Don’t write off a voucher on price. Check the numbers for the specific unit before deciding they won’t work. Ask the applicant or their housing agency what the tenant’s share would be for this unit, and write it next to your income test. As a hypothetical, if the subsidy covers most of the rent, run your multiple against the remainder only, and keep that worksheet in the file.

The same law requires positive rent reporting to be offered in new leases from October 1, 2026 and to existing tenants by January 1, 2027. That’s lease paperwork more than screening, but it belongs in the same packet you hand an approved applicant.

Not sure what your rental should earn or what this will cost you? Run the numbers in our free rental calculator at https://the-mindful-landlord.com/calculator, or call us at (443) 378-9456.

Paper rental applications and a manila folder on a wooden desk beside a window overlooking brick rowhouses in Baltimore infographic

Mistakes that cost money before anyone moves in

Check your license before you take a single application in the city. Look up the expiration date, too.

The rest has to go back after move-in or after written notice that no tenancy will happen, or you owe twice the fees. Landlords offering four or fewer units on one parcel or at one location are outside that section, and so are seasonal and condominium rentals. Keep the receipt from the screening company. Attach it to the application with a note of what you charged and what you returned.

When it makes sense to get help

A bad placement in Baltimore City starts costing money at the courthouse.

A voucher applicant whose tenant share you aren’t sure how to calculate is a good reason to get help. So is a post-offer background result that needs a written reassessment, because that document gets read closely if the applicant complains. And if an adult who never applied has started living in one of your units, our post on when a guest becomes a tenant in Baltimore covers where that line sits. Before you call, gather the application, your written criteria, the screening report and your reference notes, so the conversation starts from documents.

The Mindful Landlord manages 50+ properties across Baltimore City and Baltimore County. Our tenants page shows what we ask applicants for. Keep an eye on HB 313 as well. It would have required disclosures before collecting screening fees, and it passed the House, but its last recorded status was a Senate hearing on April 2 and it is not law.

Questions people ask

Can I deny someone for a low credit score? The new credit limits cover applicants paying with an income-based housing subsidy. For other applicants, apply whatever credit standard you set the same way to everyone and write it down before you list.

What should I do if an applicant asks why they were denied? Point to the written criterion they didn’t meet and the document that showed it. Keep a copy of whatever you send them in the application file.

Own a rental in Baltimore City or Baltimore County? Tell us about it at https://the-mindful-landlord.com/contact or call (443) 378-9456. To see the numbers first, use the free calculator at https://the-mindful-landlord.com/calculator.

More From The Mindful Landlord

What should your home rent for?

Free rental analysis. Same-day answer, no obligation.